From 8b8d970966e4cce19d4a77a75f80c712d7973104 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: feger <marc.feger@uni-duesseldorf.de> Date: Fri, 4 Sep 2020 18:10:35 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Refactor Dataset --- bilder/Ranking.png | Bin 0 -> 9220 bytes slides/dataset.tex | 67 +++++++++++++++++---------------------------- 2 files changed, 25 insertions(+), 42 deletions(-) create mode 100644 bilder/Ranking.png diff --git a/bilder/Ranking.png b/bilder/Ranking.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4af4ebbed8e3a6d2784d72015492d8359fcd3696 GIT binary patch literal 9220 zcmeAS@N?(olHy`uVBq!ia0y~yU|7z;z^Kc?#K6GtNaOiN1_tHRo-U3d6>)Fpa)$(m z-`Zf_(Nx6k>7mdNF(ae<)-<jzrlW$o3l=4au3b^s)#Sauf4x^=)?fF(Yn2RIUmf>d zeRXAQ=z?2G)?G!J=^0m<yxgCEKeY68s?*%CwbM5yDNOip%NcM({d<c*@wd(Qrk38R zmT#)O@%+u+^OpG&<{YpQh;v9_IASHNcx@)f#&a$mrD{%Vj0KbCb_%@qX^BWz!YQ>~ zWY?~z$E8&_n~4>w9k=?yetSoya?6_=_s$(k_`l)CmNko_lQ{SFFBEv~?7!P*Use6t z4}}j;Ol)4(72qX#E2h7!`=XuYSFYOuMxiOMk5s;!`k`x;R89R~#cS;|{^Uo=#C5sZ zC`QFLb)`(nEM?rf+WU=7OQYaLU0vND{Fm61Y6~WMExo=z{{6dm$F!dmX++J6?~M7O zp~x><_Mq=7>lU9A#VMc9hlM?|4@~d)>Zqcqc<|=Uo5znIKYe=jf&~leMK$LC`Q~^; zXu+4LJFE33##v8NwkY_J@PGbF>m$Duf<i;TJ~+sHLqkWWq@-j|`TMwd(W|FpZ7-e+ zi&_3|<L0ZKuOl-9`qi(UJ-D;@d4faT&rhjO?LY6&bJLS!`}V0WadO=0qVE}bd2&DU zZYf?n+vuV4>Fd|fd3O_!y!#NuQ>wQ-(nKNR^yfv3l0SUE%(l_)#gnH`H%6?{4qvD7 zf99V=Uel!OwLg|wa#`<K+-hq2%lCQ5*Mm!U?6`6C=+i$xKcA{ED?Q!b&+B}0=?)v^ zLtpoM9X@o3ZQok4j<1eO7A-n-@7}&$yLPRA;<A{<vT*B}(=P+>^lnnANQ@Ub8FMqH z)1`l^byDqy7jNEt`Tm`smpAv#)9v@`X3vcCSiA4ySw{<t!yWuL`4+QP83$E!-OqN^ zKOUG}_HSXu?>fV}Z5+!uf8;NaORC+_P$`wVQQlzEbHCo@*B)ftTCt(rDgQ}u?XRyn ztG*t4zv9r{q%H4Mxcsl>*d_#f*3{VilU~stVXn<r=a^B<94jrFV7sy7)`^|Ik?-wK z^q;$sbJu*cqJ{=Xz42Fp*J(%FR2?F7OL9Xr);{09ct!7&ufEUg*I!DztGV4*LEu6D zGP$I?YZR=jLll-~FJ@X({C7oow6)0YT!*P<uh0EnYLIi}zK`vZU6C7$FW<QCJZ<sT zry1XM_jt`N{hxH{x~@d}LcZsvRT-P@H2ddV*Of?YIc8{c*Xqobhd%b&ygyq5q+RD$ zFuNYv=YH&in9r@e-p^l;B<(4v4gJ4Ue%5Z$`~@8|Sd8Mght&Oe*skh*Z^Op&E7iGv z$shPn?}*uCmY#SbWz*y1{q8O<71h=0X=%TF<|N%J{c%KQ6JNgPo!#a7*4DSLUpF@~ z*|KHJmd%@mxwKbhy|M8rJA3x`<34+ilcwgUADo)1t*NQ0Bj&9l6uYNFa5e87x#Z-o z*RRcfKhfU)<mizJuU|WRg@=b%R#v8@sGONs{^rKV&*$wQ>x!6|n_Cz96zHGr`ny$5 z?n&INg^&OJ{k?PN&bqp~;AK9RRbMjP-P!LYDWq#_yKm~<m7n)+Vwk^w(fvCDg>P?d zEq#4$=gys~YHHW6UVV7=m1V()1)Fy_em~))-+uU{V^RN_nJ?eH`}b<~`bCQtJ&@R4 z`uf`K?fH*&OBkxOx=*L;UVmIyA+hh^&N=6wOJ6%ZRp52i=NA_j+g5+$Xg#!G!2)IX zK98kAds^+bY}v9$O!Ta*Zb|I&r#Hp#CEmQWMo40#yZhwy_%j~C!NFNsTC>l_?Wrid zzqUY)aar8MhY$7g=5Q9fJT^X6Q+CyQpMKddkAE=>D}wU=?ukvk$f?BF&Yb&Y?vj-) z5!X8}FZVw`)42Wk<GsJ%?as~3t=QT*!9&H>)pg^>jRy}Nym#-4@!Ahuw*#1-R;}Ha z*%opA$m8SvpFe+|U;pptfddDe+xcv3e~ILO%yC+?dfC>krGI~YEeMF+QIMFMs~h*X z$9c`;12-z}?WuhC?%iy&T%qox6<b3c)_ni)<fO1gd7r%fzoX*ue?A=MzkU1mN3k%L zje7elKR>&jzyIvhqQ{RP@BjBJd(SPY#4V)-Jj)K6N3egd*!uO5%j<$KZOIlgCm&Yu zxtCgOd#t-gHZ8LKqGZp-ge7c`O_Re+=9kV$l1+;@U~ir&aprhJSX;O;kM{O|UtV5z zZs%iVW3&7J=kw2>Kl|nFk3|~@t=@X?+O==*cEA5rvB$Fb*&MrCsr6}QVHtn_{QTT4 zuAjE~=E{{TeSLi^Ob^al<Gu8fvU?v3D=TN~A=~P2HdS9Z@*Q6sm0ELuUv2g4Yis4? z<N^Z&<7>Z8JvF7S<zK{>(zVxjyn6LYNLcvpojcdoMwh?6Wx8k90=CJK?f*ixC#r~x zvK~3c)zmy!WO{q-p1rkA&CN;4+r>pYzwWWAd46s#ue8~NrCe54R(*1|R;i~%?Ctm8 zxpU|D_xF!=b=WLEyr_uX<E>|3=WLW6E|~7N=5R}b^gg9@ll!+TlQ#Tcb7KpCSKiBS z#U%$>u310%v}Tsn`ws=|eCcaEOg694*|*OwP{(iD>4&1*7P6djFR~Cmbol(MGVK%V z_y6O%yw)`PTEbKN|9?LB$y&28Ii{qfR904ohl^i3P?V9G+1cIwxWHoJ!i5!g9d7M@ zvf6&N<UcQqqNfXXDoqJ(vs>rB{KyJNzrBadrkoMIxvOa2Y@xWowU^mfNG7kHzJ1FN zSNGjqt;XJ7VW(3PqGBC%w-gF<EzjKj_VvTV?UU90+xCB%GiT1eL*3%~T`o#u-BTw` zx-@<F*-3)kN7eo3`S|%=%d!2R)a{&MBBkpxQ+0)(+srWWfZ35r=1~$7E1xo7>3VqW z;e>sAHx;SOw>Q<#4|Qjc-F&KH+J$*X!)Jf`@$vET4~ClaAK29WsYp*x&&<@E^5fU9 zwDk1v{zrfLOqe)v;W?|R#=jy|lRjT;vng4~T)swc!P7Py_wuds3-ly1Wb2YI9&BFB z(p0&1YsuCq=5I-yAxmuPK0P@p|NqDFeb37h550Z+R#s4u@mH#m<h36&9p;v5rI%cD ze4^*To>jPh*OA6s6Kh1}7xYPF$X5N-@ISA*c5TUGE4DYU%|2Y@mDqUr%4&a00cq*q zhxzTlRNqeLFTJ)h?%Y?Gr)zik-CexrYG?Yf^!R-ld2&x5CPwJLm;aodZMnBU^WX*< zneX9zH*Vj4e{(Z?{qJ<Hsn<SB&k{U-_(0q}{T#k4n<~;O&+)pwsWUVz$Xga|qM-Eo z)1u_02QT&}9AxsTl;50wKJ5F91y7x~^C_3LZ;*Hu<F`4(VT0K$)pQe|O9@BT{r=!v zeBk^?A+Gc@Ga6URb+os;CnqcaTODC$5S*W%@9*u+&B@uw`}FW@hfnFIS2|+9Kb-w+ z$AyDmrJp>%p2+h^RLpGimMQPfKbZ0P<?@3E5B{*W{T&j@>!G>1^mW+IB+ayn1c_U* zU8jweV%V+2k8T(0WS+h{FK*we&BhOZl}ao-c&uU7yLT>~E%)LiKU}_JvMjW*ujt2z zhi`9he=K@lK|RkypnG*{T;I`3O{+TDtL2ZM)&{B<Kh5~X@bX1^ZE51eh>0C}c~1|w zGiG1A!6(nhTrKh9;IYr1o&o!oEKT)^nZw-vSWwFA{%ZYY-66{ZetkSHfBEudOPO;g zCMvIe%r;}@ZmyMA&39RL1n#w5oVZ}S%GTutVN9XtzB}6JZ&}H3f2sK~{h+^$tDNm$ z3qN|CK5fc{t-YQ7<)6OB7QCGFY5wWDUz+cJzn?6sy(v)Lf8T^TYi|DfG>P%$r78TJ z=VuxpzjiIGvf|FR-01!HA4#@ZYtM^nUYxl&X^QZz8U22q0jreKzqsEIY;6sFF`NC0 zo13E4%Z{vf534nm9yA|3WBy!HWXpnujK$kN%>UmKUvzBw{7a=;kDvDNoV^xq`eljR zp6c&;etv!P=f~fFDbP?Kb=H`Z?{V{miEO*J$-RCr5-6Q6V!3#u<3IN+-&q$XPye`A z<YBbcjGd~otWBx8xigGE@b2gTlE2F@HDl|%E7zXAd$+IXsTVtY`@eltYkoeR{^R|} zGf9v29G2gHacf0Dl>PO-FpVNNc`N$`V&}N$?R$0ZonJb;asL~G>ffP3n$L1>&9nXB zt!7*6b$unz+H2Q6mnysU1f<_xC6VUddoJVF3WnElbyu{vc-}Kx!1ZgdG56G%gXJ%I zpYJ+&M)K{NRqOYcJ!1J&E@p0eu~f@>_1EpUs{Vzn{l}4i{PK<K>H6+FpT5Z7&Nd}q z&#h0d;<~)VKhx%$*K0%OUQb+*mz@3k)HL0axu-7V?ft%I-H|T$;&Z|!7VE$F|6l8% z{3bBaG|tXIZLY+b&%Z=WlPey6dRp+IzV!dUCEv<stU3StxV_Wo&ns8G%hRYd)a?}) zTC`@-d+v>i4<z>Szn;C5bFpdPL&Mki%a!u$zXWOg+Oko7-(TMQ-hvxjSJ^w1zDTd# zJ?rPM+5PgtpG&Q+wcL6V_I_|W5&w_rX))V6f8SfXrtZ@}!esinRQ1{xugTMv7w+R@ z|NKwY^v8GBK;_C`eY~G$xcJH|$o^f^tvYF<)U{_zF14%<55Ke1dHp4UeA~)HX`8=B zMOBsURGoO^)o!!px<7iG=Nnh;S$X}T`Sd9Vw($O6EO%ma#aCC^WVP89vUY|471keS zPS4J|<5PZCcW<*-WlU&j>e}$Ammwk7Z_Io*YxZ~5;-@`)y`3}Dx?aE5yi&PN{prT7 z_d*v=Ixy4FY}t-|d6yO9cV3RMTs(XB?7KdN`o3vz8>So&t7M<*wPMai8{s?Nn;#W_ ze%50b9r-frPHpk-sL&-g+xG2Nz3TY1=b2>b{X2K^LuwkVk`|QiRC;Q7`$Bcf!s)BM zD|1rI-Le}_NuD+TAQ$=K=_@;jSc5yeVkXY&J^S4KRk6Jd&;186>nxvcEVW@>$Q^Pn zquefgvE28=hd=P1dpgVBVXZ`J?7E6|>RMK}yfx;metUB|uaTtBr4paY99DmummdD- zGVB*-Z=04LUokz!`}@mZj9JGbUVBZ^?2nW=S28ifH8L`&_V4^7kN!_P9eniB|CQ_g zwY9s&U(Wq>!)jjMm5KA_T+BJw;=1T#_34_vtJd?xtYatHhpWyj*;5x+7+JFDp8Ntf zpXAuilfiPvZ#~l{*EhT}So(EgQ;O~d@$3!jT2eGF%D&!skNu?E5>f3f>snIeE;n3_ z3U}JXv+BsHwcj0$y1un*UYk1M%|Wjjsj-|VMb5druAPw2nxNPGi&vri-JP9fZ)Yvl zl@WYx%X4h|-y=tlT3TE8OBx?Ldp7s|y}cD*FF3AwJmbUcy$R({&niSlM&_8^F3RIk zycU{#EB|A&@rfgy!XGa!Y>v3zGV%V6n-?!moIBUH{@))?VYQn7f4_tEzivsqe@=U< z*W^i)j`d0(fBxD2*9+x6RWB5-eLe6X|Ixjj#mnc;mF;={v8%46^mM=Zy%}2z#nV6W zu>a>Y%d2UbAUpfL&YTzWX4<;1o1>G8YHMFqe0gzko^5rDQ({2Cg^9}U3!ES8X8d^_ z|DUN<-GAN@ZILafcZI$GpYvl!_=LsUv#i9IrYt-wzxeL*3;Wn!iEdk%@+u};{rdB` znL&Y}z3<oCAKBHYA-}z^tLxK;4>xv|zJ7aq`$w^&%Gz36AC5$m57(meZ{E1EVo#y% z|JmJq`mIX$GPYO=i(U;}c9r$Yx^r7TOUOzHW(s~kYdACe`nt8z+xgO-bar-@mX`iq z&BVkcBO?=`BR1z2Hy78h@RL(57k}<o6gTs_(ZHn-=|tanaH34UY0gEKp5Nc!KY#Y@ z*Uz86GmW0UxVYG$s{PQqb?auE=dXJ6DCFFW?VANo%Py5au=kbFOLn)SAJ5K7`UY@j z=;`bC_w<NxuvnM9x$q%C?ds{+of+wt>w>@Eh<tbCsbtyH2@&!l>tc3Jnly>&c-cgc zl8=vE*O>i(&GzJw;fCqoxo3Z2)+wKND!DVQ<E!J7dwZ*I-n_YQ-@b(l7cO18^c2e> zgQW5b%^s`imvy8B);yJ7ylC-9^J}0EHChjB-3e=#-W#Rz`!f3uao@RE_sdSoan0<0 z`MMtu&n{V#7{lmwuNPD?|JP2xP#h}I^U&on?~@~!jP#E``m43&uW?9B|Mc&!fpfKI zFTOt6@W`&nnKSowN7XK#-CQ8yYP&Z#+ne`Gn$Anjno6tCbAk&3^)fuI_Ic;`%-@?K zP#hrG(_&pJww2BOvRmt4jW5UCrj&B+o#*xP{tv;>9lt})Hzqo2O-&3s>!_4)nZ0>N zeqVwLU)|%2&y-7YZLbO6UuafzF5ucm$A8(UCtjET5L<QFd~=CFvA0mqk+!FOoBS?s z4P3ZoUOk`d+68O!tz1M81<3FE=Pl^*p#R=a?S0<)7EkBN9<kZPqU>0v9B{A_R3pad zzq(o`(dGM2v*p;r&w}@-N39e8D|vsZ`JC_9d6Uj%G)=s*^P|bvuM=)&<m%n}Yrcm| zDNpz7b%w{4Raf`1{eL8N>AJ3X`a_nt&r7Fn+&abT&HB?vPm3CAzGtyqAFX$&Bf~ej zV%OKR@{9kx4>)KkvQy;djRmsvAM=U`{*F_WJRGf;x%;!p+3UjQk6Y)}W&Gecdfn#d zB6G8cTlWf1p5XE9^|aHv8;@LzoWFJFBdaa1y-Q<bB>x=lZJuX5D?ufhNqu&ites)H zePsLg60KFM-a@<1-f5>KeGMiZcxjyLQ&@X9E&lK+UF)+`Kzc&XW$>N<QJop~=Kq~F zmWw&voSycieeT%_>ig!mDWsbm^jI<H;=7u|RW@HfDV~<}H4xHDH@QA{Yt7<!&DNm) zY)wb8n{bcIL}RNi>s#kbW4Ar4w0Zww>C(vGIvODDRYh*QH>#hBG_gxwe|}wZ-~0Jx zzg}D_ZVjDW)PMeVsLb3684JM{7r6<u5i`PuXYh@>QerJGN+<u`UzE8y>2DlQ+0$T2 z*PC+p&hM9zv29Ng+3L2>D*Ca#X3Y-c<7KlrmQGoC_G`v=iMNx3*Ux_4zE<;dkBH?a zi_3>RzCB29eD^NzZ0(n-U~h+rF9!VZ@w-5k;@I#*pGDnVC;B{`#?^u7V8!asuZy&t zbJU%)a>WKvSA@%Y&;KdMpH9qY-QaN~>Ep@C>XRo=z8YC?{(iyQ*$hjsKZ+~m`1XJ0 z)2a#i3>!m?jEq8}?0-})<vlI@HfO2yRl_-(qwoHFa=T7PXzDfTfAOCUrnM*T-BVwY zzxwINljhZta$0M-)s6=|FPi1boOJ1y%_rSDG4{K^_MOib@LzHKgKzQ;vC^Jz%J*+% zCSF*(yO-bj<kFIQw&SPYPnneee5**pvU~UL&6_q&Oh|}HdhXo00XJ?aIr_!uelD^- zye;C`vkCc+w(+c5wJN}VTi#u+*3No8mtfbD;t&gq;I}#LisJkx%B2oh=eeJ_EAJcC z^8S+a<wq{9t*t*mLuz-|a5z0)X=*XcOzX|u3(`L|yqn_AFZ+`J=iT>Jnw=-|SgKML z_j%|0RBl(Xvy+1klU=mu$jw^-8Uj-n3zW9puKBvQ`OnmL!R!34=@}d3CR`Q}5oy^! zv#O(Xv(XvfhE2D??bq}9?t#*puV<eNZnd6uK|}1+j)q5NnH$dCzpW;~@xeTpe`8+Q zgt@j_6E1E28qsdYyM9}lMwxUdldk*zrf2)zbF;VP#p`U{zWq34knQ3n*bv*=c|tFK z9pK)4;YUVR*ZV{6>(?Fp9>ntUwOFs;^RN4E6mja_yDXf%T>1U<3$y1xsMc(nb6r<T zH@V_W)&Chg9S;l6>v^a<vHt(>`|@=^5`BEmoSyjE^z3!v?vID|&6v9Epw-Ov(E@AN zuC=tZeE9I;x^?Tkr|a34y}407J%7Sh%hyjH9qq3F_j$g$-<%gOU(TE}r{>ui$(13u z!o9COT+2Sw=iAro@ynMj`}OM=SL-3)*=Duh@0M36vp$)1+xYxsb^m=o9(7OE4llBp z^Web)S?jWxy;Y+5F3mCV^=d!AUXTC(>-v7Zhz$&WH;mKHoH&1ef9Y$ndmgq=;%23D z25>hy8lPZ$sv!5}ac@cU9rN^;2OOpO?iMh#AGVM=^Kb$md)c0e|0YzY=n6{o9bCZE zmS*74oG8U}E#X9)xe;HH{T^3_V4WEm2TQosVhz4FaZ30c{@|w8YV+GD<<E2b|CVKM zZd_XG{jfz=PHx`h$(L{4>N1z|IZ>SVY;pd=D@TvA#wAL7eQ--_vAJy3aY5W`;rhqD zYoypBukQ&srQwsdH(GD~RF6sBT}(;ItOpPJ-Mhkg>ges;>J}CnW@XiZ6K|BTYuvq9 zyKqY2j008eG4n!$AIr+UJMgeav@>nm)T7t0t9KneS!B8Akl7T6pB{YaP8B~QgL&Mx zB;9b*EH=1SRq5RwU$SL&fW_t|DO-KmmR)7N;v{XpupnxSoNzxozucc6kNYcDO7+BO zr1G^zw>$s(cIwo`ntxaJ><N{XEjg>j9OYCkHorcs-L-AmvSs3N6%UusuREm8mUO5! zs4ZbZX@H(pMZpvYgZ0~{tqaRO5U11lpy3$n(Nm|q%+0qKK0fwPbT7{(Crx343szq~ z1<sr29Tol3t(51+^|Qfmk2deE{(kG`&4U#Ns;aE3jSf4lyqetcRe#oO_sR;1Yo~u7 z|8py<kG*c;hQ*7MudWL1azCumCugfA-_;uQ+AaUJLDKi`&c<TnyNehFXHFNt`+iwN zeBIBdSHt7q2InOw2gk(Nv~VxI)^+b%;v_cZvb*j1vzY7prf+!8w&3)1{eDT~W&S&b zEGF^)bXxg!;rvpGBbBYKXLWR!{x-Hq@?JUnZ-UOVCr?^5!#9<^y|r$g-k)$qiN?BX z`=@%y?1(A-{3&$qT+Zw34;%2B)#*?1T4=Cy_iXS0K}^J&3l{?H?e_;Rc6)eER3~P~ zhnJU^|HyYX5c#`iy`GMYw$R11YioWOB%GDH{qS&N0zb3ujS4$W&QpJdgxajFt$+To zsH$ug6}eCza;)Uyd-IR>H9tNa>y<VzYR@bW3%mB~>+Aa!k9%KUUcUe5v)Kk0q<_2? z;Bmp*`A<yt3%z=Zoj*Z&&4vr-E(Vsom#dBMc&hr#c7wBl(BC!HY^=H&83*R*{&{Zy zP{HQ$W&f8}zmxv$EWXnC>r-l#=#f=yf91|8OLW#<Lv+mD7S>-b{l+>+{6WHkcW>rh zS$4m92aEE>^S=zLt0m?po?G_zCiAt)^X!(s4q@|o=e{9=dwtBpaLweoA^Y3kak?#< zUz#3T`**9b`hj1MmZ|OX>-g~Kk)WPl;q&vCSO0pXd+GYw?z(HB-t+V=TW;LAwQo}@ zckJ^wU0fD6XV$J;7XGz=`-#fCdtRj1cFi)}Q}DBB!|zxB{(8QBYY;jAdw+e)v*(A~ zy7%vQ&v@~=xA#=V=k51j{C3JwNUr$2X#Ur?S<hbQ+tvA;z5e#i3JJreuZOr5>wj{e zxy+`sRe?ph^4C5A?q6rGbEY}izfS5*S<<%Ea;3?`S64;L-(6U3;xfzU*^?(<e!X7r z|Ni)n!pFzH97@|PD<i{Gx2xU3-Tw7~is1E!_eV!rmA<;t(ZTWNz=ihp>-Bf8%ZmE4 zt!~@0V`odQ-??OM^>4wBXWyQjoIGQOM2v;g`n}(7-Q8XOF}^85rYf4<DLHA`%tybf zxMc2quB(3$r!`eCV#9*{MHYL)LqaBS=cyeRczyQl*}P>trmJn<b}jkAUK694IX^!= zt-bb;h2PjpUVgrA^tK7VHGMi1uQhI-I(6N#yXM<hZ@n6PwYK=e=Id)BFQ><@+i^ST z@2{^ma{TB1w)4yXd%OMqhFFeYNefCJ95~pV<NSVNYn+}yM%4>DU0vQa#TIk+P3r6G z6IS;-Gu!<9*|WNunlEqX?|*xJ&I0+i=;_*dacQ4_PW*L;pZ~DA#q`fVZ^`evzb#j~ zBR@O)@TvU!`{qubEG!^kQ1<4=nKM3B%uQiEoAknKoD)MzwoDJO2*15qUpi&eSyfeo zr2cC^Z%+SyzyAN3nZ^~F`r>*q9-f|!H~+l3x%u>|Qxd;dEMk<%j^*^(d+6|CydCGx z2L-&jUus{(y*55(@bveS$^J^p$~$B7va+(0la=o^IUF{*Hq}FA(xOF+Zrr%>;6XzE zQOE>D(yjJ)p+%pc`C4fH`1Om8jqTmt-P6x}GEMM$E#_2O`gK$4=?I-`i(I??=32SV z>sgrGdTpvr&5wfn`)U;x731RKBqb$5L-^cm$y=}e-cj{6tEy^Od%Jr^#*0Q~_APuO zGa9}|hhMsRv+~oElRth`SbXYsS+xKE-}e>W2iemkVRNWw_=4Ab|9Dz||C49W{N`9( zynp}y-tYH>yN_0MA5?_Rp0b~_U}a^k*jkx5=d0bT*RQXyi{<`&a>a@ji{1PAzHK%Q z4Gra&vuWr(bjZow{do2FcMo;Xa1^iAX1uvT=16nh59J1X);+B&EtglAJoxnVbVaLV z;;yfD4+8kvYb@RzJ}B?USfF$udIpC?=#O8&_}<=}8*#j`QLdxWQJ&{-0>g?wda1z^ zr%z|M|9NVvc13HY;<Zp_VVfDx4yN!gt1<X!?D=TZqen^N;?qArKmS-Xtv%wpQ*dyw zn;RR?9%m<~Z*OmZ|M1XxPitOCNXU)bx5LB3AB*lSIr;Q>zDL?ytw(1%N@ob<EIy%} zef)dbJc&2<+GcN?7ez0NzNB`o)JbjfT&vQoi;G+fYT~x#%w((7YP`(SBk|zG#T(xL ztDT9SCb<7pd#b?eUxnY_-Q8RLosEs{P)E+~ZMo+8_l`ubcqI4sB7?+9?bV<3w^_8f zExzb9C9>%iWCnbuYT4q}#)-S)R)w)|%u~1!9~>OKGbS%3<%#<Ink0u+))GhbZNoZm z)NE1Yk9~1Kb~Sg#PQ~*VW0#xszEZf>>!dYx+SI9M=h@Cao3?z(l9(L@jQI=M0_-eb zD-?+@VBWeTJob^pTaSIyOnRjhuK7AgM@OfnJ-e|nnVE^HsHiCK{=VMr5*$}g@0_<{ zkLdN4)l;@xeGIviw~G77uFjv|Zs$*)H0jQrJI~I}E`M}{bL!5LPpCul6|>x86|S+f zN-UDMtFcg0YC8USZT$Xy|9@%s+>kw#w4&JZ>>|d4w`Pco`tI9(@lZx??%hqP-TnRk z0RaJyjtBq#{yy1$^+LBdyZG;$9B<{*`#CS{^pe%9U!R$2>^)8A=G2*%HU>Oz^^QK3 z6kKQd#CoRgY+-Yij-ywN^sk%0N?G^h_jTQwi1F=nS3dQ=HOK-FaT}OsA9!@mod3gK z5yQHPb(!)VrJE1U74=_x@ZuKDHP#Dzf4-Q)vNSEY$^O^6<G-$Glsqf*zf%4fG%n5j zH)s!NsyeYo!0M92^=rw0=PG3}zhOG%Xcy5xqksF7*8G)qFXwcWZblnA&RMcX-pXIJ zsWe@TYkv2o?~6VM)l9!vV6{5_m08l=H46m4Wj$>y)wh3DIz!g$-nHN#uH3)&yI=UD z^5jKRTy)R-OVZ~`e=W^axpuZo);~FZ{$81<(-!Z)duX-7gZB&#&Gvg&IlhZ`{<Vws zv5jN<=Ut~XEW9KCKT(QX*WsytqVjH&pj)=g;md2o@4J@9uJ~ryRn?ruApJ#F`pL%D z6rTKpOP*%VS)Z?WjQep|V0wvq_?IA!Q@@4QzwMpjVidnUA<t7~Th-dLj?eY}im%$$ zJpDU&-Qu3ps@cWU&dxZg7T4~7$N$<x-FaQFq^vK;7JuG%W%4q?dg)$)*Uk<P&PYfH z$HZ^XoUs1R&+1ujcNMR-H#~cmraq7J-O|X9mh+Ycx_5kC_%J8+smHv)?`O~cbt?s@ zoc11Oc7ChRynEcms&+mz>7Au`tzGEFN*&};(OpY2uP|)1I|7|q{wlmHExYntYq{sP zlKFL+Qdb?<M6;YS>D9wKuGyF=73#DmS|H8)vIlW1VPKu{6aU%Qo}F~h<mQ4)3=9km Mp00i_>zopr00^P0ApigX literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/slides/dataset.tex b/slides/dataset.tex index 395d9f5..35d112b 100644 --- a/slides/dataset.tex +++ b/slides/dataset.tex @@ -3,51 +3,34 @@ \subsection{Corpus} \begin{frame} \frametitle{Corpus} - \begin{itemize} - \item For our study, we used the Webis-ArgRank2017 dataset by \cite{wachsmuth:2017a}. - \item Webis-ArgRank2017 contains a ground-truth argument graph - as well as a benchmark for argument ranking - \item The data was originally collected within the Argument-Web - \end{itemize} - \begin{figure} - \includegraphics[width=0.4\linewidth]{bilder/DatasetGlobalView2.png} - \caption{Complete Webis-ArgRank2017.} - \end{figure} -\end{frame} - -\begin{frame} - \frametitle{Corpus} - \textbf{The argument graph} $G = (A, E)$ \textbf{ is a directed graph with:} - \begin{itemize} - \item Each argument-node $a_i \in A$ consisting of a conclusion $c_i$ and a not-empty set of premises $P_i$ $\Rightarrow$ $a_i = \langle c_i, P_i \rangle$ - \item An edge $(a_j, a_i)$ is given if the conclusion $a_j$ is used as a premise of $a_i$ - \item Consequently, $P_i = \{c_1,...,c_k\}, k \geq 1$ - \end{itemize} - \begin{figure} - \includegraphics[width=0.7\linewidth]{bilder/DatasetLocalView2.png} - \caption{Part of the Argument-Web used to create Webis-ArgRank2017.} - \end{figure} + \begin{columns} + \column{0.5\textwidth} + \begin{itemize} + \item Webis-ArgRank2017 dataset by \cite{wachsmuth:2017a}. + \item Ground-truth argument graph + \item Benchmark for argument ranking + \end{itemize} + \column{0.5\textwidth} + \begin{figure} + \includegraphics[width=1.2\linewidth]{bilder/DatasetGlobalView2.png} + \end{figure} + \end{columns} \end{frame} \subsection{Benchmark Argument Ranking} \begin{frame} \frametitle{Benchmark Argument Ranking} - \textbf{\cite{wachsmuth:2017a} kept those arguments fulfilling:} - \begin{itemize} - \item The conclusion was part in more than one argument - \item Real claim - \end{itemize} - \textbf{Additionally, an argument had to be:} - \begin{itemize} - \item a valid counterargument - \item based on reasonable premises - \item logically consistent - \end{itemize} - \begin{block}{In total} - 110 argument with a total of 32 conclusions were ranked by 7 experts. - - Each annotated how much the premises contributed to the acceptance of the conclusion. - - All experts agreed with Kendall's $\tau \approx 0.36$. - \end{block} + \begin{columns} + \column{0.5\textwidth} + \begin{itemize} + \item 110 arguments + \item 32 conclusions + \item 7 annotators + \item $\tau \approx 0.36$ + \end{itemize} + \column{0.5\textwidth} + \begin{figure} + \includegraphics[width=0.6\linewidth]{bilder/Ranking.png} + \end{figure} + \end{columns} \end{frame} \ No newline at end of file -- GitLab